de Caro, Mulvehill, and Menkhoff Family Papers
Call Number
Dates
Creator
Extent
Language of Materials
Abstract
This collection contains a small selection of documents and photographs of three families of European immigrants who settled in New York City in the late 19th century. These families became connected through a series of marriages and their papers relate to a wide range of topics including marriage and courtship, the Italian-American community in New York City, Columbus Day, and travel accounts.
Biographical / Historical
The de Caros, Menkhoffs, and Mulvehills were three families of European immigrants who settled in New York and Brooklyn in the late 19th century, and eventually became connected through marriage.
Frank A. de Caro immigrated to the United States from Italy in 1884. He worked as a tailor and owned store that manufactured flags, uniforms, and banners. His company De Caro & D'Angelo Co. operated out of a storefront at 169-171 Grand Street in Manhattan. Frank de Caro was heavily involved in the city's Italian-American community and founded New York's Italian Chamber of Commerce. Frank de Caro was also a large supporter of Columbus Day and participated in efforts to have it declared a national holiday. Between 1909 and 1910, de Caro, along with other leaders in the Italian-American community, visited the White House to speak with President William Howard Taft to have Columbus Day legally recognized as a holiday. Their efforts were successful, and Taft declared Columbus Day a national holiday in 1910.
Frank A. de Caro married Anna Menkhoff In 1891. Anna Menkhoff was a German immigrant who had moved to New York with her parents August and Maria Meyer Menkhoff in the 1880s. The Menkhoffs owned and operated a pastry shop in New York, and Anna worked for her parents in the store. When Frank de Caro first started courting Anna Menkhoff, her parents expressed their disapproval and attempted to dissuade their daughter from marrying him. The Menkhoffs went so far as to buy a new piano for Anna as a way to distract their daughter from Frank's advances. They were ultimately unsuccessful and Frank and Anna eloped in 1891. Frank and Anna de Caro later had the receipt for the piano framed along with a letter Frank wrote to her parents announcing their elopement. The receipt and letter are included in this collection. Frank and Anna de Caro had seven children, Elsa, Francis, Lillyan, Frank E., Gertrude, Arthur, and William de Caro, who died as an infant. The family lived in Brooklyn at 725 Greenwood Avenue.
Frank and Anna de Caro's son Frank E. de Caro was born in Brooklyn in 1908. During the 1930s Frank E. de Caro worked as a stock broker on Wall Street and as a male model. In 1938 he married his long-time girlfriend Beatrice Mulvehill. Frank and Beatrice met at Lake Waramaug in Connecticut where both of their families spent summer vacations. The couple began dating in 1929, and eventually married in 1938. Frank was drafted during World War II and died in France in 1944. They had one son, Frank de Caro, who was born in 1943.
The Mulvehills were Irish immigrants who moved to Brooklyn in the 1840s. Beatrice's father John Henry Mulvehill (1873-1943) was born in Brooklyn in 1873 and had a successful career in the insurance business. He married Myrtle Bell Brown (1880-1963) from Russell County, Kansas and the couple had five children, Edward Leslie, John Joseph, Vincent Lyman, Urban Sylvester, and Beatrice Agnes. Many of Mulvehill's sons also worked in insurance, while their sister Beatrice worked for many years at the Brooklyn Public Library.
Arrangement
This collection has been arranged into series by format. Materials within series are grouped by subject or creator.
Scope and Contents
This collection contains documents and photographs that relate to three families of European immigrants (from Italy, Germany, and Ireland) who settled in New York City in the late 19th century. The de Caro, Menkhoff, and Mulvehill families became connected in 1891 when Frank A. de Caro married Anna Menkhoff, and in 1939 when their son Frank E. de Caro married Beatrice Mulvehill. While small and incomplete as a family history, this collection spotlights several topics, most notably, Italian-American identity in turn-of-the-century New York City, travel accounts, and middle-class courtship during the Great Depression.
Materials have been arranged into three series. Series I, Correspondence and Family Papers consists primarily of letters written by Frank E. de Caro (Frank A. de Caro's son) to Beatrice Mulvehill between 1930 and 1933, before they were married. These letters discuss their courtship as well as Frank's social life in New York and his work as a stock broker during the Depression. There are also several post cards written by Beatrice Mulvehill to her family members during a 1928 trip to Europe with a group of students from Berkeley Institute, (now Berkeley Carroll School in Brooklyn) where Beatrice attended high school. Other papers in this series relate to the first generation of the de Caro family including: documents from Frank A. de Caro's flag manufacturing company, obituaries and biographical sketches of Frank A. de Caro and his wife Anna Menkhoff de Caro, and an account of her childhood by their daughter Frances de Caro.
Series II, Bound Volumes, contains several catalogues from de Caro's flag manufacturing company, De Caro's & D'Angelo Co; scrapbooks, and travel journals. The first scrapbook in this series was compiled by Frank A. de Caro and contains letters to and from a number of Italian organization and dignitaries, which are in Italian. The second scrapbook contains photographs and memorabilia from Frank A. de Caro's daughter Lillyan de Caro Santo during a 1977 trip to Germany to visit with Menkhoff family relatives. There are also three travel journals documenting various trips to Europe and New England by Frank A. de Caro's daughters Frances de Caro, Lillyan de Caro Santo, and one by Beatrice Mulvehill (before her marriage to Frank E. de Caro).
Series III, Photographs, spans the period between the 1880s and 1990s depicting several generations of de Caro and Mulvehill family members. These images vary in size and format and include both individual and group photographs. Highlights include tintype portraits, images of the Mulvehill family at Coney Island in the early twentieth century, and a 1910 photograph of Frank A. de Caro with a delegation Italian-Americans meeting with President William Howard Taft at the White House to discuss making Columbus Day a national holiday. Photographs in this series largely depict family events, including holidays, leisure, and travel and reflect these families' attempt to document their history in the early days of photography.
Subjects
Genres
People
Conditions Governing Access
Materials in this collection may be stored offsite. For more information on making arrangements to consult them, please visit www.nyhistory.org/library/visit.
Items that include presidential signatures will be presented to researchers in duplicate form.
Conditions Governing Use
Taking images of documents from the library collections for reference purposes by using hand-held cameras and in accordance with the library's photography guidelines is encouraged. As an alternative, patrons may request up to 20 images per day from staff.
Application to use images from this collection for publication should be made in writing to: Department of Rights and Reproductions, The New-York Historical Society, 170 Central Park West, New York, NY 10024-5194, rightsandrepro@nyhistory.org. Phone: (212) 873-3400 ext. 282.
Copyrights and other proprietary rights may subsist in individuals and entities other than the New-York Historical Society, in which case the patron is responsible for securing permission from those parties. For fuller information about rights and reproductions from N-YHS visit: https://www.nyhistory.org/about/rights-reproductions
Preferred Citation
This collection should be cited as the de Caro, Mulvehill and Menkhoff Family Papers, MS 2956, The New-York Historical Society.
Location of Materials
Immediate Source of Acquisition
Gift of Frank de Caro, 2013.
About this Guide
Repository
Series I: Correspondence and Family Papers, 1890-1955, inclusive
Scope and Contents
The bulk of this series consists of correspondence from Frank E. de Caro and his wife Beatrice Mulvehill, which are contained in the first subseries. This series also contains several assorted items related to Frank E. de Caro's parents Frank A. de Caro and Anna Menkhoff de Caro. These items are included in the second subseries.
Subseries I.1: Frank E. de Caro and Beatrice Mulvehill Correspondence, 1930-1933, inclusive
Beatrice Mulvehill postcards to her family, 1926, inclusive
Frank E. de Caro to Beatrice Mulvehill, 1930-1933, inclusive
Subseries I.2: Frank A. de Caro and Anna Menkhoff Family Papers, 1890-1955, inclusive
Partnership agreement establishing De Caro and Abbate (photocopy), 1901, inclusive
Letter from Frank A. de Caro to the Parents of Anna Menkhoff, 1891 September 23, inclusive
Receipt for a piano bought for Anna Menkhoff by her parents, 1890, inclusive
Frank A. de Caro and Anna Menkhoff obituaries and biographical information, 1955, inclusive
Frances de Caro's account of her childhood, undated
Political announcement for Elsa de Caro Napolis running for Democratic state committee, undated
Cartoon by Lillyan de Caro Santo depicting her sister Frances de Caro as a court reporter, undated
De Caro & D'Angelo Inc. company envelopes, undated
Series II: Bound Volumes, 1900
Scope and Contents
This series includes travel journals, scrapbooks, and business catalogues from Frank A. de Caro's company De Caro & D'Angelo Co., Inc.
Stenna Calendario e Guida degl'Italani in America, 1893, inclusive
Language of Materials
Frank de Caro scrapbook of correspondence with Italian and Italian-American dignitaries and organizations, 1906-1936, inclusive
Language of Materials
Frances de Caro autograph book, 1910-1918, inclusive
Frances de Caro travel journal from trip to Europe, 1921, inclusive
Frances de Carol memorabilia European travel journal, 1921, inclusive
Passenger List for American Twin Crew Steamship "Republic", 1926 August 24, inclusive
Beatrice Mulvehill European travel journal, 1926, inclusive
Frances de Caro New England travel journal (in verse), 1927, inclusive
Lillyan de Caro Santo travel journal from trip to Europe, 1952, inclusive
Lillyan de Caro Santo scrapbook of her visit to Germany to see Menkhoff relatives, 1977
Catalogue, No. 15, De Caro and D'Angelo Co., Inc., 1938, inclusive
Catalogue: "Regulation Equipment for the Equestrian Order S. Gregorii Magni Pro Equitibus Civilius" by De Caro and D'Angelo Co., Inc., undated
Catalogue: "Regulation Equipment for the Equestrian Order of the Knights of the Holy Sepulchre of Jerusalem" by De Caro and D'Angelo Co., Inc., undated
Catalogo Illustrato, No. 6, Frank de Caro Italo-American Flag Co., undated
Language of Materials
Series III: Photographs, 1880-1970, inclusive
Arrangement
Photographs have been organized by family, and are generally described at the item level, although there are multiple photogrphs of some subjects.
Subseries III.1: Beatrice Mulvehill and Frank de Caro Photographs
Scope and Contents
This subseries contains photographs of Beatrice Mulvehill and Frank E. de Caro, singly and together, both before and after their marriage. It also contains photographs of their son Frank de Caro as a child.
Beatrice Mulvehill (de Caro), undated
Beatrice Mulvehill (de Caro) at college, circa 1920-1929, inclusive
Beatrice Mulvehill (de Caro) European Tour, 1926, inclusive
Beatrice Mulvehill (de Caro) in St. Mark's Square, Venice with members of her tour group, 1926, inclusive
Beatrice Mulvehill (de Caro) with her Berkeley school group in the Alps, 1926, inclusive
Beatrice Mulvehill (de Caro) at the Trevi Fountain in Rome with her European tour group, 1926, inclusive
Pope Pious XI with whom Beatrice Mulvehill (de Caro) had a private audience, 1926, inclusive
London hotel for Beatrice Mulvehill (de Caro) European tour, 1926, inclusive
Beatrice Mulvehill (de Caro) first communion, circa 1912, inclusive
Beatrice Mulvehill (de Caro), far left, with her class at Georgian Court College, circa 1920-1939, inclusive
Beatrice Mulvehill (de Caro), "Fancy dress, Atlantic Crossing", 1926, inclusive
Wedding of Beatrice Mulvehill and Frank E. de Caro at Our Lady of Angels Roman Catholic Church in Brooklyn, 1938, inclusive
Frank E. de Caro and Beatrice Mulvehill (de Caro) with friends in his Flatbush apartment, circa 1930-1949, inclusive
Frank E. de Caro, possibly at his wedding, circa 1938, inclusive
Our Lady of Angels Roman Catholic Church, Brooklyn, NY. Possibly for wedding of Beatrice Mulvehill and Frank E. de Caro., circa 1938, inclusive
Beatrice Mulvehill (de Caro) with her European tour group, 1926, inclusive
Beatrice Mulvehill de Caro and Frank E. de Caro at the front door of his family home in Brooklyn, 1944 February 13, inclusive
Frank E. de Caro, Beatrice Mulvehill de Caro on desk at his family home in Brooklyn, circa 1940-1949, inclusive
Frank de Caro, 1944, inclusive
Frank de Caro with his father Frank E. de Caro, circa 1944, inclusive
Frank de Caro childhood, circa 1940-1959, inclusive
Frank de Caro after his return from India, circa 1960-1969, inclusive
Beatrice Mulvehill de Caro with her son Frank de Caro, 1944, inclusive
Subseries III.2: Mulvehill Family Photographs
Scope and Contents
Photographs within this subseries contain images of a number of individuals in the Mulvehill family. They span several generations and cover a broad time range from the 1880s to the 1990s.
Annie C. Brown (Mother of Myrtle Belle Brown Mulvehill), 1934, undated, inclusive
Annie C. Brown with several Mulvehill grandsons and others, circa 1880-1910, inclusive
Annie C. Brown, undated
Clarissa Brown, undated
Barbara Mulvehill (Gray), undated
Beatrice Mulvehill (Palmer), undated
Beatrice Mulvehill Palmer bridal portrait, 1956 September 29, inclusive
Beatrice Mulvehill Palmer and John M. Palmer in some photos with their children, undated
Edward Leslie Mulvehill, circa 1905, inclusive
John Henry Mulvehill with sons Edward and John at Coney Island (tintype), circa 1900-1910, inclusive
John Henry Mulvehill, circa 1920-1929, inclusive
John Henry Mulvehill, undated
John Henry (Jack) Mulvehill, circa 1950-1959, inclusive
John Henry (Jack) Mulvehill, undated
John J. Mulvehill at work, undated
John J. Mulvehill, undated
Lillian Firmbach Mulvehill holding great grandchild, 1988-1990, inclusive
Lillian Firmbach Mulvehill, undated
Margo Sefton Mulvehill, undated
Mary Jane Mulvehill, undated
Mary Nassett Mulvehill, undated
Myrtle Belle Brown (Mulvehill)at Coney Island with unidentified boyfriend (tintype), circa 1880-1910, inclusive
Myrtle Belle Brown (Mulvehill) and unidentified at Coney Island (Boxed tintype), circa 1880-1910, inclusive
Myrtle Belle Brown (Mulvehill) at Coney Island with unidentified friends (tintype), circa 1880-1910, inclusive
Myrtle Belle Brown Mulvehill and her son Edward at the wedding of Beatrice Mulvehill de Caro and Frank E. de Caro, 1938, inclusive
Myrtle Belle Brown Mulvehill with her sister Agnes Brown Wagner and her daughter Beatrice Mulvehill de Caro, undated
Myrtle Belle Brown Mulvehill and Beatrice Mulvehill de Caro, undated
Myrtle Belle Brown Mulvehill, probably with great grandchild, undated
Myrtle Belle Brown Mulvehill probably with her niece Myrtle Brown Schultz O'Toole, undated
Myrtle Brown Mulvehill, undated
Urban S. Mulvehill, undated
Urban S. Mulvehill during World War II, circa 1939-1942, inclusive
Urban S. Mulvehill Jr. at his wedding with bride Diane Gregory and parents Margaret Sefton Mulvehill and Urban S. Mulvehill, undated
Vincent L. Mulvehill, undated
Vincent L. Mulvehill and John L. Mulvehill with a business group, undated
Mulvehill children at Coney Island with their nursemaid and mother, circa 1910, inclusive
John Henry Mulvehill and his son Edward at Coney Island, circa 1910, inclusive
Beatrice Mulvehill (de Caro), Brother Urban S. Mulvehill, and dog, circa 1910, inclusive
John Henry Mulvehill, Myrtle Belle Brown Mulvehill, Urban S. Mulvehill and Beatrice Mulvehill de Caro in the Catskills, circa 1910, inclusive
John Henry Mulvehill with son Urban S. Mulvehill and Mr. Evans (Urban's godfather and friend of John Henry) at Luna Park, Coney Island, circa 1912, inclusive
Vincent, John, Urban, Edward Mulvehill with other unidentified boys, circa 1912, inclusive
John Henry Mulvehill with his son John and his wife Mary at Coney Island, circa 1920-1929, inclusive
Mary Nassett Mulvehill and John J. Mulvehill possibly at Coney Island, circa 1920-1929, inclusive
Jack Mulvehill, Frank E. de Caro, Vincent Mulvehill, and Urban S. Mulvehill, circa 1920-1929, inclusive
Urban S. Mulvehill, Kevin Mulvehill, Mary Nassett Mulvehill, Mary Jane Mulvehill, possibly Urban S. Jr. Mulvehill and Margo Mulvehill, circa 1950, inclusive
Margo Sefton Mulvehill, Urban S. Mulvehill Jr., Margo Mulvehill, Mary Jane Mulvehill, Kevin Mulvehill , and Vera Sexton Mulvehill, circa 1950-1959, inclusive
Grays and Palmers, Cleveland, 1963, inclusive
John J. Mulvehill with his sister Beatrice Mulvehill de Caro and daughter Jane Mulvehill in Beatrice's Ridge Boulevard apartment, Brooklyn, 1967 January, inclusive
Unidentified woman, Vincent L. Mulvehill probably at residence of John and Mary Mulvehill on 73rd Street in Brooklyn, undated
John J. Mulvehill and Urban S. Mulvehill, undated
Beatrice Mulvehill Palmer, Lillian Firmbach Mulvehill, and Barbara Mulvehill Gray, undated
Frank de Caro with his cousin Mary Jane Mulvehill and her friend Nancy Fanelli, undated
Cousins Margo, Kevin, and Mary Jane Mulvehill, Frank de Caro, and Urban S. Mulvehill Jr., undated
Barbara Mulvehill (Gray) and Beatrice Mulvehill (Palmer) with their cousin (either Jack or Kevin Mulvehill) as children., undated
Beach Lake, PA, farm/boarding house where Frank de Caro spent some summers, circa 1920-1929, inclusive
Subseries III.3: Mulvehill Family Visits to Lake Waramaug, CT
Scope and Contents
This subseries contains photographs of gatherings at the Mulvehill family summer home at Lake Waramaug in Connecticut.
Lake Waramaug house interior, circa 1920-1929, inclusive
Group on steps of Lake Waramaug house, circa 1920-1929, inclusive
Group in front of Lake Waramaug house including Mary Nassett Mulvehill, Myrtle Belle Brown Mulvehill, and probably Beatrice Mulvehill (de Caro), 1934 September 18, inclusive
Group on steps of Lake Waramaug house including Mary Nassett Mulvehill and John J. Mulvehill, 1934 September 18, inclusive
Myrtle Belle Brown Mulvehill with group in front of Lake Waramaug house, 1934 September 18, inclusive
Group in front of Lake Waramaug House, 1934, inclusive
Group on steps of Lake Waramaug house, circa 1930-1939, inclusive
Lillian Firmbach Mulvehill, Mary Nassett Mulvehill and children at Lake Waramaug, circa 1930-1949, inclusive
Myrtle Belle Brown Mulvehill and her daughter Beatrice Mulvehill (de Caro) in front of Lake Waramaug house, circa 1930-1949, inclusive
Mulvehill family Thanksgiving, Lake Waramaug, CT, 1954, inclusive
Lake Waramaug, CT, 1996 November, inclusive
Myrtle Belle Brown Mulvehill on her lawn of Lake Waramaug house with her dog, undated
Unidentified, Vincent Mulvehill, and John Mulvehill, at Lake Waramaug house, winter, undated
Boathouse, Lake Waramaug, CT (build by John Henry Mulvehill), undated
Lake Waramaug house, undated
Subseries III.4: de Caro Family Photographs
Scope and Contents
Photographs in this series largely document two generations of de Caros between the 1880s and 1940s. It also contains several assorted images of later generations of de Caros in the last half of the 20th century.