James Thomas Flexner papers
Call Number
Date
Creator
Extent
Language of Materials
Abstract
Drafts, galleys, scrapbooks, typescripts, index cards, research notes, subject files, and correspondence of James Thomas Flexner (1908-2003), the prolific author of twenty-six works on American art, history, and biography. Flexner was perhaps best known for his three-volume History of American Painting (1947-1962), and his four-volume George Washington: A Biography (1965-1972), the final installment of which won the 1973 National Book Award for Biography.
Biographical Note
James Thomas Flexner was born in Manhattan on January 13, 1908 to Simon and Helen (Thomas) Flexner. Simon Flexner (1863–1946), a physician, scientist, and professor of experimental pathology at the University of Pennsylvania, served as first director of the Rockefeller Institute for Medical Research. Helen (Thomas) Flexner (1871–1956), a professor of English at Bryn Mawr College (where her sister served as president), was connected by family marriages to the philosopher Bertrand Russell and the art critic Bernard Berenson.
As a child James Thomas Flexner found reading and writing difficult. He overcame his dyslexia one day as he sat in Central Park staring at a page of Beatrix Potter's The Tale of Peter Rabbit, when the printed marks suddenly formed themselves into words. This achievement so inspired Flexner that from then on writing his own stories became the focus of his life. Educated at the progressive Lincoln School of Columbia University's Teachers College, he went on to graduate magna cum laude with a degree in English from Harvard University in 1929. Soon after he was hired to write human interest pieces for the New York Herald Tribune, but left by 1931 for a position with the New York City Department of Health. He resigned the following year to devote his full time to writing.
His first book, Doctors on Horseback: Pioneers of American Medicine (1937), was inspired by the work of his father. (Simon Flexner is probably best known for developing a serum treatment for spinal meningitis.) From medicine he gravitated to art history, with America's Old Masters: First Artists of the New World (1939), a study of the painters Benjamin West, John Singleton Copley, Charles Willson Peale, and Gilbert Stuart. This work, and Flexner's three-volume History of American Painting (1947–1962), helped establish the subject as an academic specialty, despite the author's lack of formal training in the field.
American history and biography, too, supplied compelling material for Flexner's talents. 1953 saw publication of The Traitor and the Spy: Benedict Arnold and John André. This was followed in 1959 by Mohawk Baronet: Sir William Johnson of New York. But George Washington would prove Flexner's most enduring and rewarding subject.
The four-volume George Washington: A Biography, appeared between 1965 and 1972. Critics hailed Flexner's portrait for demystifying Washington, for moving beyond "the marble image" and bringing the hero "down from Olympus." The final volume, Anguish and Farewell, 1793–1799, won the 1973 National Book Award for Biography and a special Pulitzer citation. In 1974 Flexner published a single volume abridgment of the series, Washington: The Indispensable Man. Flexner's Washington works were adapted as television miniseries in the mid-1980s starring Barry Bostwick as the first president.
Flexner's later biographies, The Young Hamilton (1978) and States Dyckman: American Loyalist (1980) were followed by volumes of a personal nature: An American Saga: The Story of Helen Thomas and Simon Flexner (1984) and Maverick's Progress (1996), an autobiography.
James Flexner married professional singer Beatrice Hudson (1919–1998) in 1950. The couple had one daughter, Helen. Flexner died, age 95, in Manhattan, on February 13, 2003.
______________________________
This note is based on Flexner's obituary in the New York Times, February 16, 2003 ("James Thomas Flexner, Washington Biographer, 95 Dies"), his entry in the Dictionary of Art Historians, and information from his autobiography, Maverick's Progress (1996).
Arrangement
The James Thomas Flexner Papers are sorted in twenty series. Series I through XVIII contain the research notes pertaining to one or more of Flexner's published books. Series XIX and XX contain drafts of unpublished novels, miscellaneous correspondence, and subject files. Since much of the material within each series is undated, the collection is sorted chronologically by publication date. File titles are derived from those in a 2003 inventory of the collection; these were transcribed, apparently, from Flexner's original container labels.
- Series I
- Doctors on Horseback: Pioneers of American Medicine, published 1937
- Series II
- America's Old Masters: First Artists of the New World, published 1939
- Series III
- William Henry Welch and the Heroic Age of American Medicine, published 1941
- Series IV
- Steamboats Come True: American Inventors in Action, published 1944
- Series V
- History of American Painting, 3 volumes, published 1947-1962
- Series VI
- A Short History of American Painting, published 1950, reissued 1957
- Series VII
- The Traitor and the Spy: Benedict Arnold and John André, published 1953
- Series VIII
- Gilbert Stuart: A Great Life in Brief, published 1955
- Series IX
- Mohawk Baronet: Sir William Johnson of New York, published 1959
- Series X
- George Washington: A Biography, 4 volumes plus abridgment, published 1965-1972, 1974
- Series XI
- The World of Winslow Homer 1836–1910, published 1966
- Series XII
- Nineteenth Century American Painting, published 1970
- Series XIII
- The Face of Liberty: Founders of the United States, published 1975
- Series XIV
- The Young Hamilton: A Biography, published 1978
- Series XV
- States Dyckman: American Loyalist, published 1980
- Series XVI
- An American Saga: The Story of Helen Thomas and Simon Flexner, published 1984
- Series XVII
- Poems of the Twenties, published 1991
- Series XVIII
- Maverick's Progress: An Autobiography, published 1996
- Series XIX
- Unpublished novels, undated
- Series XX
- Miscellaneous correspondence and subject files, circa 1933-1971
Scope and Contents
The James Thomas Flexner Papers include the raw materials—drafts, galleys, scrapbooks, typescripts, index cards, research notes, subject files, and correspondence—that the author used to create most of his twenty-six books on art history and American history and biography. Not every format exists for each book project. Because the collection has not been processed below the box level (it was inventoried in 2003 and rehoused but not reordered in 2019), it is difficult to know the extent of topic coverage or the date range of items. The container list below attempts to minimize the haphazard placement of related material by grouping it under its common project title. Interested researchers should consult each box listed under a particular series, except for Series XX, which contains miscellaneous correspondence and subject files that are scattered throughout most of the collection's 58 boxes.
Subjects
Genres
People
Topics
Access Restrictions
Open to qualified researchers.
Use Restrictions
This collection is owned by the New-York Historical Society. The copyright law of the United States governs the making of photocopies and protects unpublished materials as well as published materials. Unpublished materials created before January 1, 1978 cannot be quoted in publication without permission of the copyright holder. Photocopying undertaken by staff only. Limited to 20 exposures of stable, unbound material per day.
Preferred Citation
The collection should be cited as the "James Thomas Flexner Papers, MS 220, The New-York Historical Society."
Location of Materials
Immediate Source of Acquisition
James Thomas Flexner gave the bulk of the collection to the New-York Historical Society on October 11, 1974. (In the acknowledgements to his 1996 autobiography, Maverick's Progress, Flexner thanks the Society for its more than sixty years of hospitality. During that time he was accorded research and writing space in the library.) Donations of material continued through the 1990s and possibly as late as 2003, the year of Flexner's death.
About this Guide
Processing Information
A member of the New-York Historical Society's library staff inventoried the James Thomas Flexner Papers in 2003 (the year of Flexner's death). In 2019, to prepare the collection for shipment to offsite storage, stacks project archivist Elise Winks rehoused it in record cartons and revised the 2003 inventory to include newly-assigned box numbers. Processing archivist Joseph Ditta based the present finding aid (2019) on Winks' updated inventory. The materials in the collection have not been sorted or thoroughly examined, hence the scattered filing of related items and the vagueness of dates.
Repository
Series I. Doctors on Horseback: Pioneers of American Medicine, published 1937, inclusive
Doctors on Horseback – Daniel Drake, Ephraim McDowell, The Death of Pain [card file], before 1937, inclusive
Doctors on Horseback – John Morgan, Benjamin Rush [card file], before 1937, inclusive
Doctors on Horseback – William Beaumont, Credits, Illustrations, Bibliographies [card file], before 1937, inclusive
Doctors on Horseback [manuscript], before 1937, inclusive
Series II. America's Old Masters: First Artists of the New World, published 1939, inclusive
America's Old Masters – West [card file], before 1939, inclusive
America's Old Masters – Copley Notes [bundle], before 1939, inclusive
America's Old Masters – scrapbook of reviews, 1939-1940, inclusive
America's Old Masters [manuscript], before 1939, inclusive
Series III. William Henry Welch and the Heroic Age of American Medicine, published 1941, inclusive
Later / Clintonville Welch [folder], before 1941, inclusive
Series IV. Steamboats Come True: American Inventors in Action, published 1944, inclusive
Steamboats – After Publication – Correspondence [folder], before 1944, inclusive
Steamboats (1 of 2), before 1944, inclusive
Steamboats (2 of 2), before 1944, inclusive
Steamboats [page proofs], before 1944, inclusive
Series V. History of American Painting, 3 volumes, published 1947-1962, inclusive
Volume 1: First Flowers of Our Wilderness: American Painting, the Colonial Period, published 1947, inclusive
First Flowers – Land Scene List [card file], before 1947, inclusive
First Flowers of our Wilderness Before 1730 – Smibert – Feke – 18th Cent. Artists Alphabetical [card file], before 1947, inclusive
Glass plate negatives – First Flowers of the Wilderness (offset section – 11/7/67), before 1947, inclusive
First Flowers [manuscript], before 1947, inclusive
First Flowers [page proofs], before 1947, inclusive
Volume 2: The Light of Distant Skies (1760-1835), published 1954, inclusive
Light of Distant Skies Artists [card file], before 1954, inclusive
Light of Distant Skies – 2nd Half [card file], before 1954, inclusive
Light of Distant Skies [manuscript], before 1954, inclusive
Volume 3: That Wilder Image: The Native School, published 1962, inclusive
19__ – Volume III of the History of Painting [card file], before 1962, inclusive
Wilder Artists, A-Z [card file], before 1962, inclusive
Wilder Image – Artists A to D [card file], before 1962, inclusive
Wilder – Categories [card file], before 1962, inclusive
Dover Publications reprint (1970) of That Wilder Image, 1970, inclusive
That Wilder Image II (1 of 2), before 1962, inclusive
That Wilder Image II (2 of 2), before 1962, inclusive
Series VI. A Short History of American Painting, published 1950, reissued 1957, inclusive
Pocket Book – Post Vision [card file], before 1950 or circa 1957, inclusive
Series VII. The Traitor and the Spy: Benedict Arnold and John André, published 1953, inclusive
Arnold – Notes & Play (1 of 2), before 1953, inclusive
Arnold – Notes & Play (2 of 2), before 1953, inclusive
Traitor Reviews – Duplicates (1 of 2), before 1953, inclusive
Traitor Reviews – Duplicates (2 of 2), before 1953, inclusive
Benedict Arnold – Television Script, before 1953, inclusive
Arnold Play [folder], before 1953, inclusive
Final Draft, Traitor & Spy, before 1953, inclusive
Series VIII. Gilbert Stuart: A Great Life in Brief, published 1955, inclusive
Stuart [draft], before 1955, inclusive
Stuart Harding / Columbia Bits [card file], before 1955, inclusive
Series IX. Mohawk Baronet: Sir William Johnson of New York, published 1959, inclusive
Johnson, 1767 – Categories [card file], before 1959, inclusive
Johnson – Appendix – Illus. – Names Not sorted [card file], before 1959, inclusive
Johnson – Birth – 1764 [card file], before 1959, inclusive
Sir William Johnson – Chaps I-IX – First Draft, before 1959, inclusive
Sir William Johnson – Mohawk Baronet, before 1959, inclusive
William Johnson Chronology [folder], before 1959, inclusive
Mohawk Baronet Page Proof [envelope], before 1959, inclusive
Mohawk Baronet – Final Draft [envelope], before 1959, inclusive
Series X. George Washington: A Biography, 4 volumes plus abridgment, published 1965-1972, 1974, inclusive
Volume 1: The Forge of Experience, 1732-1775, published 1965, inclusive
Forge of Experience – Rough Sheets / Gallies [sic], before 1965, inclusive
Washington – Volume One [card file], before 1965, inclusive
Volume 2: George Washington in the American Revolution, 1775-1783, published 1968, inclusive
Washington II [card file], before 1968, inclusive
Washington – Revolution I [card file], before 1968, inclusive
Working Carbon of George Washington in the American Revolution, before 1968, inclusive
Washington – Revolution II [card file], before 1968, inclusive
Washington II – Second Draft [envelope], before 1968, inclusive
Manuscript – George Washington in the American Revolution (sealed box containing mss from Little Brown and Company to JTF, postmarked 5/27/66), before 1968, inclusive
Manuscript – Washington in the Revolution, before 1968, inclusive
Volume 3: George Washington and the New Nation, 1783-1793, published 1970, inclusive
Washington III – General [card file], before 1970, inclusive
Sheets: Washington in the American Revolution. A few carbons, Vol. III (1 of 2), before 1970, inclusive
Sheets: Washington in the American Revolution. A few carbons, Vol. III (2 of 2), before 1970, inclusive
Washington III carbon with corrections [microfilm reel], before 1970, inclusive
Sealed box containing mss [George Washington III] from Little Brown and Company to JTF, postmarked 1/8/71, before 1972, inclusive
Volume 4: Anguish and Farewell, 1793-1799, published 1972, inclusive
Sealed box containing mss [George Washington IV] from Little Brown and Company to JTF, postmarked 4/11/73, before 1972, inclusive
Washington IV – Final Draft to Typist, before 1972, inclusive
Washington IV [2 microfilm reels], before 1972, inclusive
Abridgment: Washington: The Indispensable Man, published 1974, inclusive
Sealed box containing mss from Little Brown and Company to JTF, postmarked 2/22/82 [holds manuscript of Washington: The Indispensable Man], before 1974, inclusive
[George Washington materials, uncertain placement]
Early Drafts – Washington (1 of 2), undated, inclusive
Early Drafts – Washington (2 of 2), undated, inclusive
[Washington] [card file], undated, inclusive
Washington 1984 [hanging file], 1984, inclusive
From: Early Drafts Washington [folder], undated, inclusive
[George Washington] [galley], undated, inclusive
[George Washington], undated, inclusive
Flexner – Washington, undated, inclusive
Douglas Southall Freeman, George Washington: A Biography, vol. 6, "Patriot and President", 1975, inclusive
Series XI. The World of Winslow Homer 1836–1910, published 1966, inclusive
Time Correspondence / World of Winslow Homer [folder], 1964-1965, inclusive
Sheets for Winslow Homer – Washington for [rest of label missing], before 1966, inclusive
Series XII. Nineteenth Century American Painting, published 1970, inclusive
19th Century Painting – Corrections Carbon, before 1970, inclusive
19th Century American Painting – Original Ms. with Flexner and M.R. [Milton Rugoff] corrections – this does not go to printer, before 1970, inclusive
Flexner – Painting – Central – Gathered for 19th Cent. Book [card file], before 1970, inclusive
Series XIII. The Face of Liberty: Founders of the United States, published 1975, inclusive
Two copies of published volume., 1975, inclusive
Series XIV. The Young Hamilton: A Biography, published 1978, inclusive
Hamilton, before 1978, inclusive
Flexner – Hamilton Original Draft, before 1978, inclusive
Hamilton – Copying Draft [envelope], before 1978, inclusive
Series XV. States Dyckman: American Loyalist, published 1980, inclusive
Dyckman, before 1980, inclusive
[States Dyckman], before 1980, inclusive
Boscobel c. 1977 – English tvp. 1978 – Mount Vernon & Son & Lumiere, circa 1977, inclusive
Series XVI. An American Saga: The Story of Helen Thomas and Simon Flexner, published 1984, inclusive
Helen Thomas Flexner (mother)
Helen to Bertie – Annotated copies of letters from Helen N. Thomas to Bertrand Russell [hanging file], circa 1903-1929, inclusive
Done to be filed – Notes re "Bertie-Helen," copies of letters from Helen to Bertie, copies from Bertrand Russell's America and review of same from "Studies in History of Society," Vol. II, Nos. 1 and 2, Fall and Spring, 1970 [folder], 1970, inclusive
Copies of letters from Alys R. to Helen Thomas [folder], circa 1899-1928, inclusive
Mildred Whitall – Correspondence, photographs [file], before 1984, inclusive
Helen to Bertie B Series – Copies of letters from Helen to Bertie [envelope], before 1984, inclusive
Helen – 19003 [sic] – Non Courting – Notes, annotated copies of correspondence, drafts, correspondence [envelope], circa 1903?, inclusive
M. Carey Thomas – Diary – Copy [envelope], before 1984, inclusive
Thomas S. Whitall – Backgrounds Pearsall Smiths – Research notes [envelope], before 1984, inclusive
Helen – 1897 – Misc. re that date – Grace's Troubles – Notes, copies of correspondence [envelope], circa 1897?, inclusive
Helen Whitall Flexner – Mother's Papers – Letters to William / Philosophical Society – Correspondence, before 1984, inclusive
Thomas, 1860-1880's – Death of Mary Whitall – James Carey Thomas – Research notes, drafts, copies [envelope], circa 1860-1880s, inclusive
Helen 1889-1896 – Research notes, drafts, copies [envelope], 1889-1896, inclusive
Simon Flexner (father)
"1925" – Notes on S.F. Diaries, correspondence, passport Loose drafts & correspondence [hanging file], circa 1925?, inclusive
Simon Flexner Diary, 1921-1925 [photocopy], 1921-1925, inclusive
Simon – Copy Flow of Diaries [photocopy], before 1984, inclusive
James Thomas Flexner's Note on Autobiographical Conversations with Simon Flexner [folder], circa 1936-1939, inclusive
Simon Flexner – University of Penna. – Scientific Work – Drafts, notes, research [envelope], before 1984, inclusive
Simon Hopkins – Research re SF at Johns Hopkins, notes, etc. [envelope], before 1984, inclusive
Abe & Anne – Flexner Siblings – Research notes, drafts, copies [envelope], before 1984, inclusive
Simon – Louisville – Flexner Background – Research notes, correspondence, drafts, copies [envelope], before 1984, inclusive
Flexner Simon – Life 1900-1903 – Rockefeller Institute – Research notes, drafts, copies [envelope], 1900-1903, inclusive
SF Flexner Diaries I, 1917-1920 [photocopy, 4 folders], 1917-1920, inclusive
General
Notes – American Saga, before 1984, inclusive
American Saga Ms., before 1984, inclusive
American Saga – Final Carbon – 1-25 [envelope], before 1984, inclusive
American Saga – Final Copy – 26-50 – Carbon [envelope], before 1984, inclusive
American Saga – Source References – Carbon [envelope], before 1984, inclusive
American Saga [final draft?], before 1984, inclusive
Series XVII. Poems of the Twenties, published 1991, inclusive
Poetry Notebook I, undated, inclusive
James Thomas Flexner Verse, 1924-1931, inclusive
Series XVIII. Maverick's Progress: An Autobiography, published 1996, inclusive
"A Rage to Write: The Making of a Biographer – Box Two" – Typescript, before 1996, inclusive
Freshman at Harvard – Copies of letters from JTF to his parents, n.d. [folder], [1925], inclusive
Sophomore / Harvard 1926 – Annotated copies of letters from JTF to his parents, n.d. [folder], 1926, inclusive
Junior-Senior / Harvard – Annotated copies of letters from JTF to his parents, n.d. [folder], [1927-1928], inclusive
Series XIX. Unpublished novels, undated, inclusive
"Dogs Shall Eat Jezebel" – Xerox [envelope], undated, inclusive
"Enter and Possess" [typescript], undated, inclusive
Series XX. Miscellaneous correspondence and subject files, circa 1933-1971, inclusive
A-R – Assorted files of correspondence and admin. material (1 of 2), 1951-1962, inclusive
A-R – Assorted files of correspondence and admin. material (2 of 2), 1951-1962, inclusive
A, 1963-1971, inclusive
Adams I – Adams Notes for Historical Society [card file], undated, inclusive
Ag's letters – Correspondence [folder], undated, inclusive
American Heritage, 1962-1971, inclusive
Article Ideas [card file], undated, inclusive
[Autobiographical notes] [binder], undated, inclusive
B, 1963-1971, inclusive
Bushnell—Material, undated, inclusive
C – culled 1952 – Correspondence [folder], 1945-1950, inclusive
C, 1963-1971, inclusive
Century Association, through 1971, inclusive
City Noise, vol. II [page proofs], undated, inclusive
Columbia Caper – Notes [folder], undated, inclusive
[Correspondence] Assorted files of correspondence and drafts (Reviewed by JTF October – November 1992), 1940s-1950s, inclusive
[Correspondence] Assorted files of correspondence and drafts, 1950s-1970s, inclusive
D, 1963-1971, inclusive
Dictionary of American Biography, supplement three, 1941-1945, 1973, inclusive
Digressionists, undated, inclusive
E, 1959-1971, inclusive
English Articles – Correspondence, mss [folder], 1945, inclusive
F, 1959-1971, inclusive
Faquanzi's Muses [card file], undated, inclusive
Farrar Straus, undated, inclusive
[Financial] Personal financial records, including tax returns and correspondence, 1952-1967, inclusive
Financial, 1953-1957, 1962-1963, inclusive
For Writing Anthology [folder], before 1998?, inclusive
Scope and Contents
Material perhaps intended for Random Harvest (1998), a collection of Flexner's essays, reviews, and other writings.