AFSCME, Local 420, Hospital Workers, represents a wide range of non-professional workers employed in the New York City municipal hospitals and health centers. Until the 1950s, city hospital workers, many of them Black or Latino, were among the lowest paid of municipal workers and remained outside the organized labor movement. Registered and practical nurses, aides, orderlies, clerical assistants, laundry workers, maintenance workers and truck drivers often worked in unsafe and unsanitary conditions. Their concerns, when hospital organizing began, were not only with pay, benefits and opportunities for advancement, but also with issues of respect and dignity on the job. At this time, the city hospital system consisted of 21 hospitals. In 1955 the fledgling Local 420, consolidated from several older units comprising AFSCME, District Council 37's Joint Board of Hospital Workers, had fewer than 500 members citywide.
AFSCME District Council 37 director Jerry Wurf assigned several organizers to the Local, with a view to increasing its size and challenging Teamsters Local 237, which was then the most influential union in the city hospital system. Among the key organizers in the early years were Jean Couturier, Harold Staley, James Farmer, and James Butler. Despite determined opposition from administrators, the Local grew steadily and some basic improvements in working conditions were achieved. By 1964, when Wurf moved to Washington as AFSCME International President, the Local had grown to nearly 5,000 members, while the Teamsters claimed 6,500. New DC 37 head Victor Gotbaum stepped up the drive among hospital workers, and assigned his assistant, Lillian Roberts, to the campaign. Roberts, a former nurse's aide who had joined AFSCME in 1946, promised on-the-job training programs to move workers into better-paying jobs, decent treatment from supervisors, fair grievance procedures and collective bargaining. Gotbaum, meanwhile, enlisted the support of A. Philip Randolph, Bayard Rustin, George Meany, the New York City Central Labor Council and a number of AFL-CIO union presidents on Local 420's behalf. By the fall of 1965 Gotbaum was ready to take on the Teamsters in a representation election. Local 420 deployed newspaper ads and radio spots in Spanish and English, biweekly bulletins, door-to-door canvassing at workers' homes, palm cards, buttons, and stickers to reach the workers.
In December 1965 hospital workers voted in the representation election and Local 420 won among most categories of employees. The following year the Local, headed by president John Coleman, negotiated an agreement with City, providing for pay increases, welfare fund contributions by the City, and a dues check-off. The election gave DC 37 a majority in the hospitals and also among non-uniformed city workers; this success spawned new gains in organizing, and by the end of 1966 the Council represented more than 80,000 city employees. Over the next few years the Local continued to make steady gains through bargaining, but there was continued concern over waste, inefficiency in management, and understaffing at municipal hospitals, while city officials made more concessions to private hospitals. Steady pressure from DC 37 blocked plans by the Lindsay administration to lease or fully privatize several hospitals, but was the beginning of a struggle to defend public hospitals and their unionized employees.
In 1972 James Butler was elected president of Local 420, and took on the battle for better pay, benefits and educational opportunities, and against privatization and hospital closings. Born in Savannah, Georgia and educated in Tampa, Florida, Butler studied at City College in New York, and took a job at Fordham Hospital in 1954. Butler was to lead the Local through the citywide fiscal crisis in the mid-1970s and led tp increased membership, reaching an estimated total of 14,000 in the early 1990s. He raised the public profile of the Local through rallies, marches, and involvement in community affairs and a firm commitment to national and international campaigns for civil rights and human rights. Butler's political agenda was furthered by Local officers such as Secretary-Treasurer (from 1984) Kendreth Smith, Executive Vice-President (from 1996) Sarah Kennedy, Vice-President Alejandro Ruiz, Political Action Chairman, James Webb, and many others whose work is reflected in the archival records.
Under Butler's administration, the Local, established the City Hospital Worker newspaper; the Voices of Local 420 choir; and participated in the Coalition of Black Trade Unionists, the New York State Black and Puerto Rican Caucus, the Coalition of Labor Union Women, Jesse Jackson's Operation PUSH, the NAACP, the National Urban League, the Southern Christian Leadership Conference's Labor Committee, and other labor and civil rights organizations. The Local became a leading force in ASCME DC 37's Hospitals Division and in AFSCME's Health Advisory Committee. Local 420 members traveled to the South to support civil rights and labor struggles, and involved in the campaign to have the birthday of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. birthday established as a national holiday.
As a result of the staunch opposition of Local 420 and DC 37, the Giuliani administration was prevented from selling off the Coney Island, Elmhurst and Queens hospitals, as a first step toward dismantling the city hospital system. Despite the reluctance of other New York labor leaders to confront a popular mayor, President Butler organized rallies, prayer vigils outside homes of city officials, and a "Freedom Bus," which followed the mayor on the senate campaign trail. A landmark court decision blocked the sale of entire facilities, but Giuliani pushed ahead with cutbacks in funding of the Health and Hospitals Corporation, reallocation of Medicaid funds to private hospitals, closures, and privatization of some hospital services, with the result that the Local's membership dropped to 7,500 and the number of municipal hospitals to 11 by 2001. Clashes between Butler and DC 37 executive director Stanley Hill meant that the Local could no longer count on firm Council backing in negotiations. In the late 1990s, dissent began to grow within the Local, as members questioned lavish expenditures by the leadership, a burdensome dues increase, and plans for an expensive new local headquarters that never materialized.
In December, Local vice-president Carmen Charles, representing the opposition within the Local, challenged James Butler for the presidency and won. Despite repeated challenges to the election result by the Butler slate and inaction by DC 37, Charles's victory was finally confirmed by AFSCME's national Judicial Panel in May 2002. The new administration embarked on a program of revitalization and reorganization, aimed at defending the some of the city's most vulnerable municipal workers.
Sources:
Bernard and Jewel Bellush, Union Power and New York: Victor Gotbaum and District Council 37(New York: Praeger Publishers, 1984).Dierdre McFadyen, "Butler's Last Stand," City Limits Monthly(on-line), November 2001.Silver Anniversary Celebration of Jim Butler, October 11, 1997 (New York: AFSCME, Local 420, 1997).
